Alpine Plumbing & Rooter Logo

AC Replacement Quote Comparison Worksheet for San Dimas Homeowners

Compare AC replacement quotes by matching equipment, installation work, permit handling, testing, and warranty coverage before comparing totals. San Dimas lists air conditioning replacement as work requiring a permit. Use the worksheet below to record what each contractor includes, then request written prices for missing items before choosing a proposal.

Why AC Replacement Quotes Need a Local Paperwork Check

San Dimas homeowners need to compare the paperwork behind an installation along with the equipment. The City of San Dimas permit guidance specifically lists furnace and air conditioning installation or replacement as work requiring a permit. A quote that leaves permit handling unclear needs follow-up.

The city also provides mechanical permit applications and HVAC handouts. Ask each contractor to identify the permit process for your property and explain any added steps if the outdoor unit will move. Compare proposals for the same location and scope before judging the price difference.

Homeowners Comparing Different Replacement Scopes Need This Worksheet

This worksheet is for owners of existing homes comparing two or three replacement proposals. It is especially useful when one quote keeps the furnace, another replaces it, or a third proposes a heat pump.

Before requesting estimates, write down:

  • The rooms that stay warm or receive weak airflow.
  • Whether you want cooling replacement only or changes to heating too.
  • Whether the outdoor unit will stay in its current position.
  • Any planned additions, window upgrades, or insulation work.
  • Access limits, including attic entry and locked side gates.

For a condo or townhome, ask the association whether equipment placement or exterior work needs approval. Confirm the permitting authority for the actual property address, particularly if it is outside city limits.

The Worksheet Reveals What Each Quote Actually Covers

Record written answers in every row; a blank means unresolved, not included. Give each contractor the same comfort concerns and ask them to distinguish required work from optional upgrades.

Property address: ____________________ Date: ____________________

Comfort concerns: __________________________________________________

Contractor A: ____________________ Contractor B: ____________________ Contractor C: ____________________

Item to compare Quote A Quote B Quote C
Outdoor unit brand and exact model _____ _____ _____
Indoor coil model; air handler or furnace kept/replaced _____ _____ _____
Cooling capacity and sizing calculation provided _____ _____ _____
SEER2 efficiency rating for proposed equipment combination _____ _____ _____
Equipment match documentation, such as AHRI certificate _____ _____ _____
Duct inspection; sealing or replacement scope _____ _____ _____
Refrigerant lines reused/replaced and reason _____ _____ _____
Thermostat, drain work, pad, and electrical work _____ _____ _____
City permit handling and fees included/excluded _____ _____ _____
Required energy testing, paperwork, and fees _____ _____ _____
Startup checks and results supplied _____ _____ _____
Inspection scheduling and correction responsibility _____ _____ _____
Old equipment removal and cleanup _____ _____ _____
Parts warranty, labor warranty, and exclusions _____ _____ _____
Equipment availability and installation duration _____ _____ _____
Inspection/testing visits and closeout estimate _____ _____ _____
Total installed cash price before incentives $_____ $_____ $_____
Separately priced required exclusions $_____ $_____ $_____
Optional upgrades, listed separately $_____ $_____ $_____
Financing APR, term, fees, and total payments _____ _____ _____
Quote expiration and written change-order process _____ _____ _____

Ask how the contractor determined capacity. ENERGY STAR's installation guidance recommends sizing equipment for the home's actual characteristics and checking airflow, refrigerant charge, and ducts. Simply choosing the same capacity as the old unit leaves the sizing question unanswered.

For documentation, ask for a load calculation, such as Manual J or an equivalent method, and the proposed equipment match. These are among the items in ENERGY STAR's bid comparison checklist.

Options, Costs, and Timing Depend on the Agreed Scope

Compare prices only after you know which equipment and installation work each option covers. An AC replacement, a full heating and cooling replacement, and a heat pump conversion are different proposals.

Option When to discuss it Installed cost Timing to request
AC and indoor coil replacement while keeping a compatible furnace Existing heating equipment may remain suitable Client range not provided; obtain a site-specific quote Availability, installation duration, testing, and inspection
Full heating and cooling system replacement Both systems need assessment or replacement Client range not provided; obtain a site-specific quote Equipment lead time, workdays, and closeout visits
Heat pump conversion You want to evaluate combined heating and cooling Client range not provided; obtain a site-specific quote Compatibility review, electrical scope, and completion schedule

For each quote, calculate a comparison total: the base installed cash price plus written prices for required excluded work. Avoid counting the same charge twice. Keep optional upgrades separate, and treat an unpriced required item as an unresolved cost.

Record incentives separately until the contractor identifies the current program and confirms eligibility for your equipment and project. For financing, compare total payments and fees alongside the cash price. A lower monthly payment alone does not show which offer costs less.

Ask for separate estimates for installation, cooling downtime, and paperwork closeout. Equipment delivery, added electrical work, testing, and inspection scheduling can affect different parts of the timeline.

Local Permits and Energy Testing Belong in the Written Scope

Ask each contractor to name who will obtain the permit, pay fees, arrange inspections, and provide completion records. The San Dimas inspection page allows homeowners or contractors to request inspections. It also says an adult homeowner, contractor, or authorized representative must be present. Assign that visit before installation begins.

California's 2025 Energy Code took effect January 1, 2026. Have the contractor confirm which code cycle and requirements apply to your permit and replacement scope.

The California Energy Commission explains that field verification and diagnostic testing is prescriptively required for most HVAC alterations. Required tests are identified on the project's Certificate of Compliance. Ask which tests apply, who arranges them, and whether the quote includes the fees.

The current program uses Energy Code Compliance, or ECC, terminology. Older quotes may say HERS testing. Ask the contractor to clarify the applicable documents rather than assuming either label describes the complete scope.

Questions to Resolve Before Choosing a Quote

Do I need a permit to replace my AC in San Dimas?

Yes. The city's permit guidance lists air conditioning replacement. Ask the contractor to include permit handling and identify who will arrange inspection.

Why do AC replacement quotes include different equipment?

Contractors may propose different scopes, such as retaining a furnace or replacing the entire system. Ask each to explain equipment compatibility and submit a clearly labeled comparable option where practical.

Should I choose a larger air conditioner?

Ask for a sizing calculation based on your home. ENERGY STAR warns that oversized equipment can cycle too frequently; a larger unit should have a documented reason.

Is energy testing included in the replacement price?

Check the written scope. Ask the contractor to identify required testing from the compliance documents and list testing, paperwork, and correction responsibilities.

How do I compare the final prices fairly?

Add separately priced required exclusions to each base cash price and keep optional items separate. Resolve missing prices, warranty terms, and closeout duties before selecting a proposal.

Bring Your Worksheet to an Alpine Replacement Assessment

Alpine Plumbing, Heating, and Air provides AC installation and replacement in San Dimas. Bring your worksheet and comfort concerns to an AC replacement assessment and request a written proposal covering equipment, installation work, permit responsibilities, testing, and warranty terms.

Alpine Plumbing, Heating, and Air
Welcome to Alpine Plumbing and Rooter, serving San Dimas and the surrounding areas as your reliable source for exceptional plumbing and drainage services. We also provide reliable licensed HVAC services.
get free estimates

Ask for FREE Estimate here!

After reviewing your information, we will contact you as soon as possible.
Alpine Plumbing & Rooter Logo
© 2026 Alpine Plumbing, Heating, and Air. All Rights Reserved.
phone-handsetcalendar-fullcross